The Amazing Case Of Bridie Murphy: Reincarnation Or Deception? - Alternative View

Table of contents:

The Amazing Case Of Bridie Murphy: Reincarnation Or Deception? - Alternative View
The Amazing Case Of Bridie Murphy: Reincarnation Or Deception? - Alternative View

Video: The Amazing Case Of Bridie Murphy: Reincarnation Or Deception? - Alternative View

Video: The Amazing Case Of Bridie Murphy: Reincarnation Or Deception? - Alternative View
Video: Bridey Murphy a case of reincarnation 2024, March
Anonim

This incident, which occurred in 1952 in Pueblo, Colorado, thrilled believers in reincarnation and spawned an army of skeptics.

In November 1952, amateur psychotherapist and hypnotist Maury Bernstein suggested to his friend Virginia Teague to put her into a hypnotic sleep.

The girl turned out to be very susceptible to hypnosis and this pushed Mori to a strange experiment. He decided to find out if Virginia could remember what happened before her birth.

To the doctor's surprise, the girl suddenly spoke with a strong Irish accent. She said her name was Bridi (short for Bridget) Murphy and she lived in Ireland during the 19th century.

Over the next six sessions, she gave out more and more details about her life. According to the girl, she was born in 1798 in Cork, and her parents were named Duncan and Kathleen. At 17, she married Sean Brian Joseph McCarthy and moved to Belfast. She passed away at the age of 60 and even remembers watching her funeral.

In her speech, she used archaic Irish expressions and described many details - dates, names, places and even the names of stores.

On the basis of this incident, in 1956 Bernstein published the book "In Search of Murphy's Groom". It immediately became a bestseller.

However, he was criticized by priests, doctors and journalists. And inconsistencies began to emerge in history.

Promotional video:

Inconvenient facts

Soon all the headlines were full of revelations of Bernstein and Teague.

The first disappointment came after the parish records did not reveal any information about Bridie Murphy and her husband.

Then the Chicago priest Wally White, whose church little Virginia attended, joined the story. He stated that the girl has always shown a keen interest in everything Irish. Later, he became the main source of revealing information about Virginia Teague.

In addition, it turned out that in Chicago, not far from Virginia's home, there lived an Irish woman named Bridle Corkell, who apparently became the “prototype” of Bridie Murphy.

But that was not all. It turned out that for some time an Irish aunt lived with the Virginia family! Apparently, her stories were deposited in the girl's subconscious and became her "memories from a past life."

Journalists were also skeptical about the words that Bridi grew up in a wooden house - at that time in Ireland, the main materials for construction were clay and brick.

Finally, Bridi revealed that she had a stillborn younger brother. It was said that Virginia herself had a younger brother who died in infancy.

These and other controversial facts undermined the confidence of the public, which only yesterday admired the mysterious story of the transmigration of souls. Bernstein was declared insane and Virginia was a liar. It seemed to be over.

Exposing the Whistleblowers

However, Dr. Bernstein was not going to give up without a fight. With the help of a journalist friend from the Daily Post, he managed to publish an article in the newspaper refuting all the facts that did not fit into his story.

And it turned out something interesting - some of the whistleblowers invented and misinterpreted facts from the life of Virginia.

So, the girl had never heard of the Reverend Wally White until the moment he appeared on her doorstep in 1956 with the words: "I will pray for you." And everything that he told reporters was nothing more than his fantasies.

Also, Virginia did not have a stillborn brother or Irish aunt. That is, she had an aunt, but she was born in Chicago and did not live long in the girl's family when she was 18 years old.

As for the wooden house, it is not clear on the recording (and all sessions were recorded on tape) whether she said that the house was “good” or “wooden”.

The records of Bridie Murphy might not have survived because the written records of the population in small parishes at that time were very bad.

What was true was the Irish Chicago neighbor. But the families never really spoke, and Virginia was too young to become her friend. In addition, Bridle Corker had never been to either Cork or Belfast, so she could not tell the girl about these places.

Conclusion

Interestingly, after the publication of this article, the whistleblowers did not refute the information indicated in it in any way. Could this serve as a proof of their bad faith?

And was this a real case of reincarnation? The controversy continues today.